Wellwerefucked

This is what boggles my mind!

gopluckyourself

nah

gopluckyourself

your gender is irrelevant bud

redditsuckz

They used them recently on the No Dapl(Dakota Access Pipeline) protesters;

POLICE USE MICROWAVE WEAPONS ON DAPL PROTESTORS

THE MILITARIZED POLICE USE NOT ONLY LRAD ON PROTESTORS BUT BREAK OUT THE SHORT MICROWAVE TECHNOLOGY AGAINST TRIBAL PROTESTORS, PROTESTING AGAINST THE PIPELINE THAT IS DECECRATING THEIR ANCESTORS BURIAL GROUNDS.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DN5CH-VHSbw

Balour

squidicuz

Well... At least they found employment after this past election cycle!

Wellwerefucked

Thats one way of looking at it! Haha

ALDO_NOVA

also, he was reading from a scripted statement, not speaking freely from the heart.

he was told what to say and couldn't even pull that off without looking nervous and guilty as hell.

BTW protecting these sites from shills of VERY important, they are trying to get it all shut down or convoluted to the point where no one is on the same page.

rational discussion is one thing, but outright calling it fake and a conspiracy without backing it up or debunking anything...is useless to us

https://www.reddit.com/r/conspiracy/comments/5gsnof/ctr_allegedly_used_pornography_to_shut_down/

quantokitty

Look, not for nothing, but they are going ballistic over the basement at Comet thing. There's post after post now of the basement being at Bucks -- all these posts AFTER it was proven and put in print that there is a basement and that Alefantis admitted there was one.

I'm going to post more about this because there is an anomaly in the real estate information. Yes, the information is still there proving there is a basement both at Bucks and Comet, but something is left off both properties.

I think maybe a PI should be hired only for this. I mean, why not? If it costs $500 for them to find out that's 500 people paying in $1. There are usually more than 2,000 people plugged into this forum at any given time. They are really, really going f*cking crazy over this. I don't know how many posts I saw yesterday debunking there was one and there a particularly ugly shill involved -- a real piece of work. Once we prove there's a basement, it's game over for them.

NO, DO NOT VISIT THERE AND SELF-INVESTIGATE OR CALL AND HARASS WORKERS EARNING A LIVING! NO ONE IS SUGGESTING THAT. Apparently, we need this caveat now.

TheCoonlol

I upvoted the shill comment...WTF? (I can't remember doing it) http://prntscr.com/dggh7m

After I saw that I removed my "upvote" (FYI I can't Up/DownVote for another couple of hours) http://prntscr.com/dgghld

Maybe I did it by accident, but HELL NO would I like that comment??!!

Wellwerefucked

Wow thats very perculiar... worth making a post about possibly if you find any more instances!

pizzahthrowaway

I'm the guy who pointed out the shill in the 300 upvote picture post about ctr shilling right now, I'm an oldfag so I'll tell you how he's a shill...

When I posted that he was a shill, I got INSTANT 10 downvotes (specifcally enough to hide me) and he replied about "if I'm a shill why are you posting fake news" here's the thing, my only post was a post questioning a room in a picture that HE (james a) posted, but he's talking to me like I'm some kind of lead investigator, when all I do is reply....no sense of place...does that help clarify?

I'm sure its strange because these guys have very advanced tactics for this

LostandFound

Yeah report to the admins they are actually really good. I spotted a group posting articles on a burger joint over the space of a few days then staged an AMA with an employee that was receiving 'threatening' calls. Called it for what it was 100% shilling lots of the contributors had negative scores it was a mess. But it got cleared up. Just remember what Ghandi said 'First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win. '

IITJACKII

I feel like in some way the shills are exploiting the framework of voat's upvoat / downvoat functions. As a new member I can only upvoat until I hit the minimum 100 comment contribution points. Maybe they have created or purchased a variety of accounts most new, allowing them to mass upvoat posts that they favour. More worrying would be them gaining control of accounts that have the minimum comment contribution points, which would allow them to mass downvoat as well.

Wellwerefucked

Surely mods/voat as a whole has some integrated tools to detect/prevent this & yet nothing.

redditsuckz

Pizzagate Shillz

32+ upvotes from SAME COMPUTER;

https://i.sli.mg/TPCJeA.png

http://i.sli.mg/InQuNf.jpg

GoodGodKirk

they don't have to focus on that other site anymore...

ababcb

If something important is being downvoated we need to make multiple threads on the same topic to both increase visibility and divide the shills' attention.

Wellwerefucked

I like this. Repost something important & link to the previous post that got buried not only repromote the original information but continue to create shill awareness.

cosmicmind

WE must be careful to vet information on the thread discussions thoroughly, because these terd floaters will try to sabotage by feeding false information.

ababcb

You can often just "tell" that it's a Shill. The best way to be sure is to check the account age and post history of anyone who appears skeptical about pizzagate. From my limited experience a shill account will be completely one sided and full of hostile, ad hominem attacks.

Gorillion

One of the tells is that the person uses odd terminology or comes at topics from obtuse angles. As a newbie you may not have caught on to Voat's way of talking about things and so more resemble a shill than a goat.

For example: I had to read your comment about Alephantitis' feelings about the camera being moved a few times to figure out what your angle was.

One tactic of CTR during the election was to make reasonable sounding comments that were ultimately trying to muddy the waters. Introduce notes of doubt etc. It's hard to explain to a newbie why these more subtle shills stand out, because they just do.

Sure legit newbies will get called shills, but we can't slow down for them. They have to catch up with us. Learn where it's appropriate and acceptable to demand evidence or speculate on different motivations or causes behind aspects of the investigation. And watch out for unnecessarily obtuse language. Autists in general don't like wishy-washy language and will default to downvoating as a quick problem solving response so they can move on with the real focus of their attention.

So if you all want to go ahead and participate in group think over upvotes, then I am going to leave.

Don't make ultimatums like this. Leave or don't leave. This reads as concern trolling and criticism of a system that's actually working and successfully exposing the people and networks behind these crimes, and that alone will get you downvoated.

Contribute where you can. Be a positive member of the community. These are the things that will get you accepted.

superesper

As other users have noted ( https://voat.co/v/pizzagate/1467451) ) the shills are here. What should we do?

We should undertake a psychological campaign of demoralization/repetetive-negative-entrainment against them. Every time you see an obvious shill comment, reply along the lines of:

Every time you post one of these comments you are protecting people who torture, rape, and murder children.

...

You are a person who gets paid to protect child rapists.

...

Every time you see someone you love, you will think to yourself "I get paid to protect child rapists".

etc., in your own phrasing, with your own twist, or exactly the same, doesn't really matter. Even if there are four replies like that already on the comment, make another one. If there's one thing we've all learned from experience with shills, it's that they do check their inbox, diligently. The idea is to repetitively confront them with what they're doing over and over and over again and build a negative psychological response into their psyche. Never engage with the content of their post in any way . If they reply to you, no matter what they say, just write another one of those messages telling them very directly what they're doing.

The messages shouldn't be angry either. For two reasons, firstly, shills are trolls, secondly, (I'm not no god damn psychologist but bear with me) anger makes the message less effective at working it's way into the shill's psyche. When some angry person yells at you "fuck you, you're a fucking retarded asshole" that's just an angry person being angry and you can more or less laugh it off. Anger prompts an immediate denial/defense/dismissal response. When large numbers of people are repeating a message to you in clear, direct, unemotional language, presenting you with nonthreatening, straightforward sentences that just happen to be designed to build habits into your cognition (e.g. the third example), the knee-jerk anger defense reflex isn't triggered and the ideas are processed more deeply.

At some point the shill will either quit out of inability to deal with the cognitive dissonance, or, by some unlikely miracle, actually grow a conscience and realize what they're doing. It's my guess that the majority of shills are bad people but they're not psychopathic, mass murderer, pedophiles, they just have weak morals and want the pay, or they've bought some kind of political brainwashing. Some of them can be broken with repetition. If you just write a few of these replies and keep them in text somewhere, you can just paste them whenever you see a shill. Originality is not necessary. Only truth and repetition.

Pasting one of these replies is hardly any more effort than downvoating, and aside from the potential for breaking shills, it also leaves a public visual indication of the unified recognition that the user is a shill.

Wellwerefucked

Good insight & advice.thank you for this.

Anti-Stupid

The scripts are probably more used to reddit's usual traffic.

Gumbatron

BlueDrache

It reads almost like a Saul Alinsky novel.

Apantslessman

Maybe we where not infiltrated but maybe they where already here.... Doesnt voat have a large pedo membership?

dmcindc

I only get 10 freaking votes a day on voat... it really sucks! Whoever thought of that is a moron.

Gumbatron

That is not generally an easy thing to determine conclusively, and in the end it's up to each of us to consider the validity of any other users comments.

As a general rule, if I see a comment that appears shill like (ad hominem attacks, changing the subject or bringing up irrelevant or pointless information, many others. I remember reading a good guide on it, but can't seem to find it at the moment) then I would generally look at the commenters history. Perhaps that comment was a one off, or they were just annoyed or overly passionate about a particular issue. But, looking at someone's comment history you can get a pretty good idea of whether they're legit.

Another thing to watch out for is their supporters. They often travel in packs (maybe the same individual with different accounts, or maybe a team of individuals). Often you can see them backing each other up, or teaming up against someone.

Having looked up your comment history, I would be confident in thinking that you are not a shill.

Wellwerefucked

The comment itself looks like it was a pre-programmed post with 2 bullshit MSM links

Phobos_Mothership

I feel as though they will not get the responses that they wanted out of their shilling, and they will move on to more MSM slandering of our cause.

Wellwerefucked

Yeah your post is fine, its the First comment that concerns me!

eMalum

He's not talkin' 'bout you, bud.

OPs refering to this comment: https://voat.co/v/pizzagate/1466440/7100103

Shook

Pretty easy to buy bot votes these days. You have to start not looking at upvotes and downvotes as a way to measure whether or not a comment has validity, do your own research, make your own judgement, and don't blindly follow the top upvoted comments everyone.

eMalum

Fuck it, take my voat.

CCP isn't nearly as impactful as submission voter fraud. Sure, gaming comment votes is active censorship that we should be vigilant against, but you don't see entire nations practically falling to their knees just because one dude had a popular opinion.

When entire teams of educated media watchdogs stage a coup for control over what submissions are allowed to be digested by the layperson... well, that's when you start seeing the kneelers and all of their popular opinions.

When the playing field is level, when everyone has an opinion and a say and a voat , that's when true capitalism takes over... the best stuff rises to the top and the garbage gets thrown out. Also fuck spez.

Wellwerefucked

That last paragraph hits the nail on the head.

standalone

The problem is that visibility is a function of score. Downvoting critical posts will allow to send them so far behind the front page that no-one will ever find them. We can't just shrug off the attack. Either we can make sure that mods are able to identify and ban shill accounts who participate in that kind of manipulation. Or we have to start looking for another platform better suited to prevent that kind of manipulation.

ababcb

If something is getting downvoted we need to make multiple threads on the same subject.

The_Awakened_One

As long as everyone sees it for what it clearly is. The instant this place turns into Reddit 2.0, I'm out.

angular_planes

It helps us discern the genuine dummies from the paid shills, thanks guys keep it up!

Stukov

I wonder if those people who are shilling have actually ever looked at the evidence and realize they are being paid so someone else can keep molesting, raping, and eating children.

standalone

To accept a job that essentially involves seating behind a computer, disrupting people's conversations and planting lies, you have to have a pretty light sense of ethics. So I'm not holding my breath that paid shills would suddenly have an epiphany and realize how pathetic they are as human beings.

Stukov

It's one thing to basically be a paid troll or whatever, it's another to cover up the massive abuse/rape/torture/murder that is going on to innocent people and children.

standalone

Shills aren't told to cover up. They are told that #pizzagate is a fake conspiracy theory fabricated by Russians, that must be disrupted in all ways possible.

CJJacobs

Just call them out and keep on moving! We've got truth on our side. :)

standalone

It's important to look into it. They could easily take over the sub and subvert the investigation. Truth may be on our side, but a quick look out there shows that so far it hasn't done much to help us create awareness. Making sure that the platform we use is able to resist manipulation is paramount.

CJJacobs

I agree.

We are the resistance though.

It requires every person of goodwill to call it out, repeatedly. People of goodwill on this sub are doing that. We just need to keep it up!

I do thank you for making this post, as we need to know when a larger-scale attack is underway. Thank you!

Wellwerefucked

We need to keep on top of the trends of disinfo, because if everyone is at least on the same page in how to indentify a shill, you'll have all of their attempts ignored. Ignoring but documenting their efforts is best!

ArchonFall4All

The more they fight us, the more the movement grows. I've been researching pizzagate from the very beginning, and I've witnessed these people constantly shift their tactics to find something that works. Never has a "conspiracy theory" been attacked so hard, which should speak volumes to anyone with a discerning mind

redditsuckz

Pizzagate Shillz

32+ upvotes from SAME COMPUTER;

https://i.sli.mg/TPCJeA.png

http://i.sli.mg/InQuNf.jpg

zoot3d

I love you. Good job.

cosmicmind

I love The Truther Movement as pertaining to #pizzagate. Truthers unite!

Wellwerefucked

When the random tinfoil hat wearing crazy person becomes an army of investigators that recruit new members every day... it must be scary as fuck for the Elite.

ababcb

They are so frightened I'm getting worried they might unleash some kind of pandemic. When they can't control us they will want to kill us.

Gumbatron

If we all get in and downvote the main shill comments, they'll disappear pretty quickly. There are a lot more of us than them.

Having said that, I'm pretty new around here and don't have enough up votes to down vote. So if anyone feels like throwing me an up vote that'd help me out a lot :-)

fromfiction1984

Yup, many of us don't have the 100 upvotes just yet, and it only lets me upvote 10 times a day, don't know if it increases over time..

very_concerned

Tried to down vote but don't have enough points also.

Wojo7s

Same problem here....no voats left to give.

N14C

im newbie. how do i upvote ? i would like to add a point to you to make it 10 points

BadGuacamoleTV

A Lot of us that jumped from Reddit dont have to 100 upvotes it takes to DV these guys.

BlackSwordsman

Man. I tried to make a post when we all got booted off Reddit, saying be sure to upvoat contributions so we can combat this, and I got absolutely SLAMMED like I give a shit about internet karma. I said it before and I'll say it again, use your upvoats for those of us in the fight here!

standalone

Voat isn't sybil attack resistant. With enough resources, they can easily outnumber us. With 45+ accounts able to vote, it will be easy to activate more and more new accounts. Unless mods can identify and ban shill accounts who do the voting, Voat may not be viable in the long run.

d3r

But the new accounts can only upvoat. Maybe the top 3 posts will always end up as the shill posts.

grlldcheese

This is exactly what happens.

It's game theory based on simple rules. Upvoat each other. Shit talk the shills.

At the beginning of any exodus they have the advantage because they cheat and collude. As the exodus gains experience, their advantage disappears. Power through it.

bagelbitchsnap

i think we need to create posts for upvoating so we can all contribute to this sub

r3dtr1x

It would appear so. I'm staying objective, was once a pizzagate enthusiast, and today finally came to reason.

But yeah, looks like we are being invaded.

draugur

Fuck off already.

anon123

Great. They're done with their fight in MSM article comments and are now coming back in here.

draugur

We clearly have been. The inundation of nonsense, bullshit etc posts also points to this fact. All the more reason to take this "debunked conspiracy" even more seriously.

Millennial_Falcon

This is why I was in crisis mode trying to recruit mods a week ago, and then got jumped all over by the protectvoat crowd worried about a slippery slope of censorship.

Wellwerefucked

We need a new platform. Something unheard of that provides the same ability as Reddit & Voat.